OC tag problems

Tagging Discussion » OC tag problems Search Posts
Anonymous #B060
On Furbooru, essentially all character category tags are styled in the form of character (franchise). But oc category tags don’t follow this same system. In fact, 273 out of the 372 existing OC tags have no extra information other than the character name. This will undoubtedly lead to conflicts down the line.
 
After asking a staff member about this, and bringing up the possibility of conflicts, I was informed that the person who next encountered a name conflict could simply append a new (parenthesized designation) to the OC tag name. But this leads to problems, beyond the relative unfairness of the first-come first-serve nature of these tags…
 
For example, there are plenty of existing cases on Derpibooru where there are multiple OCs with the same name that inadvertently shared the same tag name, which leads to a problem because these entirely different OCs may then become indistinguishable for search or for filtering purposes. In addition, there was at least one case where a conflict resulted in an actual altercation between users.
 
Another problem that was raised was the problem of there being community ocs, or characters which have essentially lost their original ownership due to popularity, but are not canon to a particular source material - sort of like a generic trademark.
 
Upon asking about these cases, I was informed (rather unexpectedly) that these cases would be recast as the blue character category tags, even when these characters are not canon to a particular source material. This was because I had an implicit expectation that the blue tags were generally reserved for officially licensed/trademarked characters, and that the OC tags were primarily fan creations.
 
So if this is intended to actually be the case, and not just something that was poorly communicated to me in private, is there any meaningful distinction between the character category and the oc category? If there isn’t, could you please explain your rationale?
Parashy
Red Gem - For donations to the site
Birthday Fur - Joined within the first year of the site operation and has had significant amount of activity as of June 1, 2021.
Astra - Helped choose the name for our mascot - Astra.
Passing of the Eclipse - Joined within the first month of public opening and has had at least some activity as of August 3, 2020.
Since the Beginning - Registered before the site was public

I’d prefer to axe oc and just use character. There’s less of a reason to make a distinction between media-originated characters and someone’s fursona here than at derpi, and the lines are a bit murkier here.
 
Also when it comes to first come first serve on names, I lean towards popularity. If one character has 50x the posts of another I’d rather just omit the (owner) part because most people are probably looking for that. If they’re similar enough just (owner) both of them. That’s what I’ve always done in the past and it’s worked pretty well to avoid conflicts.
CruFox
The 1% - Hit 1% of Uploads Milestone for a year
Even Worse Kobold -
Birthday Fur - Joined within the first year of the site operation and has had significant amount of activity as of June 1, 2021.
Tag Master - Exceptionally Good and Proficient Tagger
Derpy Fur - Prevented Furbooru's terrible fate in April of 2021.
Dedicated Lifter  - Uploaded over 5k art pieces
Seedling - Gave the site life with many uploads during its first months
Heavy Lifter -
Astra - Helped choose the name for our mascot - Astra.
Passing of the Eclipse - Joined within the first month of public opening and has had at least some activity as of August 3, 2020.

Moderator
I like tags
@Anonymous #B060  
@Raptorshy
 
Because only staff can edit tag descriptions I was personally always placing the owner of the oc in brackets when tagging unless:  
  1. the name was composited of first and last name and they sounded original enough  
  2. in the cases where owner name was the same as character name.  
    I am also trying to always check if there is a reference sheet available and upload it as the first image tagged with the oc:name, as it is an alternative option to specify clearly who the character owner is - this information will be in the ref sheet image description.
     
    Also a good reason for using oc:name format is that everyone can do this and the tag will be in a different color, whereas the blue character tags must be set by staff and thus needs to be reported in a forum thread. This seems like a lot of work because there are tens of thousands (if not more) of furry original characters.
     
    I still think users should be able to change color of tags on their own like on e621 but as this not the case this is the only option to enable ordinary users to make the tag colorful (well, this and artist: and comic:).
Anonymous #B060
There’s less of a reason to make a distinction between media-originated characters and someone’s fursona here than at derpi, and the lines are a bit murkier here.
 
Can you explain why this is? I think there is a reasonable, meaningful distinction to be made between someone’s fursona, and say, judy hopps.
Interested in advertising on Furbooru? Click here for information!
KilianKuro Commissions!

Furbooru is not cheap to operate - help support us financially!

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide